in our house we;re debating the merits of having a backyard versus the evils (and expenses!) of having to own a car.
heres (roughly) the 2 sides of the debate, forum link at bottom:
"(going to the suburbs) it's like, who sucked the life out of the air, and what did they do with the people??? Yards are nice, but a playground you can walk to -- not to mention some ethnic eats and a handful of bars -- makes life more entertaining for everybody, I think."
"If you stay in the city with kids, you graduate to a different phase -- more dinner parties and kid focussed activities, punctuated with the book readings and art openings (a few times a year in my case but still the presence of the possibility makes a diffference to me) that i always enjoyed."
or
"My husband and I both grew up with back yards to play in and the relative safety of a neighborhood full of kids. I would LOVE for Jillian to have that kind of wild and free childhood and not have to rely on "playdates" and structured play areas."
"You can always drive into the city, or stay with friends there. I would sorely miss the spur of the moment ability to go see a band-- but I dream of a yard with kiddie pool, barbecues, and beer......."
http://www.babble.com/CS/forums/1/982/ShowThread.aspx